YC has played an instrumental role in building Airbnb, Stripe, Reddit, DoorDash, Sendbird and Daily. Furthermore, its philosophy on startup building has become ubiquitous today – helping companies scale as a result. As a startup founder looking to experience similar success, it can be daunting to navigate startup valuation. Thankfully, YC has various valuation methods to help founders during this process. Each of the following methods offers unique insights and understanding their nuances aids founders in making informed valuation decisions. There are also various platforms and discussion chains revolving how to choose the best valuation method for your startup[1] where “top experts” offer their advice.
1. The Berkus Method
The Berkus Method is one of the easiest and simplest ways to assess startup valuation. Founders can use it to value their company without needing to estimate future financials – something which is notoriously difficult when considering that startups involve high investment risks.
This method focuses on five essential factors commonly present in pre-revenue startups: product, team, market size/growth potential/competition and competition. Each element is then assessed for risk; low-risk elements receive an “+” score while those considered high risk get a “-” one. Once combined together these scores provide a pre-money valuation.
As when using any method, when applying this approach it is vital to exercise extreme care when assessing competitors. Valuations of similar companies may differ dramatically based on location, industry and year of incorporation. You could find a startup in Silicon Valley offering similar products and business models; yet its success metrics might be vastly different than your own business’s metrics. Therefore it is essential that this technique be combined with others that focus on real revenue generation.
Unfortunately, this method fails to consider all of the risks that investors take when investing in startups, such as intellectual property rights and intangible assets that add value. It doesn’t consider these important considerations when assigning values for startup investments.
2. The Combination Method
Participating in Y-Combinator can be the realization of many founders’ dreams. Considered one of the world’s most successful accelerator programs, Y-Combinator has launched companies valued at over $400 billion since 2008. It offers seed stage funding in exchange for equity stake in your company along with advice and mentoring from experienced entrepreneurs.
Despite its success, Y-Combinator isn’t the only place for entrepreneurs and startups to gain exposure to investors; numerous incubators, boot camps, and accelerators have since opened using similar strategies as those pioneered by YC.
At Demo Day, the culmination of each YC cohort’s three month intensive work period, each startup receives one minute to present themselves and their company’s value porposition to potential funders. Problematically, however, this approach emphasizes what founders think their company should be worth rather than what the market actually values it for. Even if their product is revolutionary and solves major problems for people everywhere, this alone doesn’t generate massive valuations; therefore, founders should focus more on metrics which matter to customers rather than ones considered valuable by investment communities.
3. The Multiple Method
The Multiple Method teaches founders that there’s more to a startup than its assets. It takes into account human and monetary aspects of business operations which may be difficult to measure for pre-revenue startups.
As part of their early-stage investment journey, founders also learn the art of accepting more dilution than they would like – an invaluable lesson when seeking early-stage capital as the amount of equity awarded often depends on how valuable their company is seen to investors.
Mendelson suggests taking a cue from realtors when using this approach: it compares a startup against similar ones. Mendelson advises founders to identify comparable businesses that share similar business models and financial metrics (for instance Enterprise Value (EV) to trailing 12-month revenue or EBITDA). Mendelson advises starting this process online, followed by consulting lawyers who can provide quarterly updates of VC financing deals they have seen.
Once potential investors know a startup’s valuation estimate, they can assess whether investing makes sense. More importantly, knowing this number enables founders to create realistic fundraising needs and request more funding accordingly.
Valuing a startup requires considering both quantitative and qualitative factors, such as team experience and brand strength. Understanding the risks involved with various valuation approaches will enable you to make informed decisions when raising capital from investors or angels – this way both parties remain on the same page and any surprises don’t pop up later! Utilizing the correct valuation methodology will allow your startup to unlock its full potential.
4. The Discounted Cash Flow Method
Valuing any company isn’t always straightforward, and valuating startups that haven’t yet generated earnings or revenue is even harder. Without track records of earnings to show for themselves yet, valuing such businesses can often prove even more complex than anticipated.
As such, it’s essential for founders to gain an understanding of how different valuation methodologies can help them assess the value of their startup. Although valuation remains an art rather than science process, these methodologies provide an effective means of simplifying and increasing accuracy for early stage startups.
One of the most widely used techniques for determining startup value is discounted cash flow analysis (DCF). This process involves forecasting future revenue and market share acquisition, working capital requirements estimation, and calculating present value of expected future net cash flows of the company. By discounting future cash flows using an appropriate risk-adjusted rate of investment return, total market value can be easily established.
DCF valuation methods are used by venture capitalists, private equity funds and investment banks when analyzing tech startups for investment or M&A deals. Startup founders should gain an understanding of this method so they can make informed decisions regarding whether a DCF valuation of their business would be suitable or not.
Other methods for valuing startups beyond discounted cash flow analysis are cost-to-duplicate and book value evaluation. Book value uses only fair market values of assets belonging to a startup. On the other hand, cost-to-duplicate requires extensive forecasting that may fail to capture all its potential, without taking into account time value of money. This is because startups often take years before realizing their true worth.
5. The Market Value Method
Calculating the value of your startup requires taking both human and monetary factors into consideration. When valuing a startup, both are equally essential – with cash needed to start up being one component while market potential and investor buzz being others. Although some aspects are easier than others to measure when it comes to human values, founders must learn how to balance both when negotiating with investors.
One of the most widely-used valuation methods is comparables, which teaches founders how much their startup may be worth once profitable and at scale. Comparables also assist founders in recognizing any areas where their startup might be over or undervalued in the market. If investors have shown much interest but you have yet to generate any revenue, you may need to update your pitch deck to provide more data substantiating your claims and support them more convincingly.
The Book Value Method (BV Method) calculates company worth by deducting liabilities from assets in order to provide a more tangible assessment. However, it doesn’t take into account intangible assets which could add to its worth such as potential growth or other intangible elements that might contribute to its valuation.
Finally, the scorecard valuation method is an objective approach to measuring startup worth that assigns weights to different elements of its worth, such as its management team or target market size. Unfortunately, this approach may be inaccurate if weights are not evenly balanced or when startups have few tangible assets at early stages.
Overall, Y-Combinator’s valuation strategy for startups have multiple approaches from the Berkus Method to the most widely used Discounted Cash Flow Method. As a startup founder it is important to account for the limitations of each approach and find a way to balance quantitative and qualitative factors to make informed decisions. Doing this intricately through extensive brand assessment allows for increased capital, building credibility with investors, and unlocking your startup’s full potential.
[1] https://www.linkedin.com/advice/1/how-do-you-choose-best-valuation-method-your-startup
#:~:text=Choosing%20the%20best%20valuation%20method,later%2Dstage%20may%20use%20comparables